Skip to Content

5 Casually Romantic Restaurants in Ozaukee County Area

Whether you are looking for an affordable restaurant for a special occasion like Valentine’s Day or just to have a nice date night, here are a few suggestions. If you want to guarantee a table we suggest calling ahead to find out if you need reservations or the estimated wait time.

We also recognize that not everyone has the same definition of a romantic dinner, so some suggestions may seem more fitting to your taste than others. Most of the time I prefer a nice, yet casual place for date night. All of these places are in or around Ozaukee County.

5 Casually Romantic Restaurants

MELTING POT 19850 W. Bluemound Rd., Brookfield, WI

There’s something about dipping pieces of food into melted cheese and chocolate that equals romance. It’s a departure from the ordinary dining experience and one I keep hoping to have some day.

THE PASTA SHOPPE 323 N. Franklin St., Port Washington, WI

Italian food almost always sounds perfect to me for a date night. Maybe it’s because pasta is comfort food at its finest or maybe I need to blame Lady and the Tramp. Either way, I love going to The Pasta Shoppe. It is casual, but still has a warm, intimate atmosphere. Plus, you can color love notes to each other on the paper table cloth cover.

BEANIES 102 E. Grand Ave., Port Washington, WI

Some would advise you to stay away from spicy food and beans when out with your lover for a quiet, intimate evening. Well, I happen to like going to Beanies for their delicious Mexican food and margaritas. It’s also more relaxed, so I feel comfortable there on date nights. Sometimes they have live music too. (Yay, mariachi bands! I never know if I should stop eating while they play or not?)

HIGHLAND HOUSE 12741 N Port Washington Rd., Mequon, WI

A vibrant atmosphere with colorful artwork, refreshing margaritas and a menu of Caribbean and Mexican style dishes. The also have a delicious birthday dessert – one I’m willing to put up with public embarrassment for!

We have gone to each of these places except the Melting Pot and enjoyed our dinners there. Most importantly we found them to be affordable while still casually romantic. I’m not cut out for upscale expensive dining that requires me to wear a dress. I’ll go for business casual any day.

If you’ve never tried one of these locations before I hope you’ll consider one of them on your next night out. What local place do you like to go to for special occasions?

OLIVE GARDEN 18180 Blue Mound Rd., Brookfield, WI (also one on Brown Deer Rd.)

Again, not a swanky establishment, but it feels more grown up than your average family restaurant. Plus, they have wine and calamari. Oh and I can’t get enough of their breadsticks.


Friday 5th of November 2021

Beanies is not delicious .... coming from authentic Mexican culture----- this tastes nothing like the real thing. However, it is really cute in there and the people are really nice. I was just a bit disappointed with the food.

Darcy Zalewski

Wednesday 10th of November 2021

I'm sorry to hear you did not enjoy the food there. It's definitely cute inside and those swings are unique.

Liz Smith

Sunday 3rd of August 2014

You might want to check your geography. Brookfield is in Waukesha County and about 30 miles away from Ozaukee county. You could have looked at the wonderful restaurants in Cedarburg and Mequon.

Darcy Zalewski

Sunday 3rd of August 2014

If you actually read what I wrote then you would not have missed where I said "in or AROUND Ozaukee County." That is still accurate. It's AROUND the area and is an easy drive (I know, I've driven it on more than one occasion). I could have looked at a lot of different places but these were the ones I chose as MY top 5. You could have listed your suggestions instead of telling me to check my geography which is frankly quite rude.


Friday 15th of February 2013

The Melting Pot sounds fun! I have always wanted to try a place like that or own a fondue fountain! And no, the one at Golden Corral does not count, lol!